Shirley NY FSBO Homes (199)

Sort By

List
Map

We have 199 homes for sale by owner in Shirley, NY. The median list price in Shirley, NY is $751,048 and the average price per square foot is $128,774.

Homes For Sale

$679,999

6 Bed
4 Bath
2,500 Sqft
0.25 Acre(Lot)

14 Victory Avenue, Shirley, NY

Amazing duplex! nestled in brookhaven township, right of route 27. great for extended family. this is an income... Read More

Homes For Sale

$199,999

2 Bed
1 Bath
656 Sqft

192 E Parkview Drive, Shirley, NY

Handyman special!!! this bungalow is a perfect canvas for you to make it your own. the home features a layout... Read More

Homes For Sale

$529,999

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,200 Sqft
0.22 Acre(Lot)

55 Candido Avenue, Shirley, NY

Welcome home to this renovated 3 bedroom, 2 full bath expanded ranch in northern shirley. as you enter the home,... Read More

Homes For Sale

$525,000

2 Bed
1 Bath
800 Sqft
0.25 Acre(Lot)

36 Westminster Drive, Shirley, NY

Beach lovers look no further ! this location offers a beautiful landscape with walking distance right down the... Read More

Homes For Sale

$585,000

4 Bed
2 Bath
2,132 Sqft
0.25 Acre(Lot)

55 Ridgewood Drive, Shirley, NY

This beautifully-maintained 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers the space, flexibility, and charm you’ve been... Read More

Homes For Sale

$465,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,517 Sqft
0.23 Acre(Lot)

5 Stuart Road, Shirley, NY

Step inside this spacious 3 bedroom 2 full bath ranch with a primary bedroom ensuite. the two other bedrooms are... Read More

Homes For Sale

$525,000

2 Bed
1 Bath
800 Sqft
0.25 Acre(Lot)

36 Westminster Drive, Shirley, NY

Beach lovers look no further ! this location offers a beautiful landscape with walking distance right down the... Read More

Vacant Land For Sale

$139,000

0.25 Acre(Lot)

150 Grand Avenue, Shirley, NY

Residential vacant lot – 0.25 acres in prime shirley location build your dream home on this spacious 0.25-acre... Read More

Homes For Sale

$830,000

5 Bed
6 Bath
4,318 Sqft
0.95 Acre(Lot)

10 Deer Path, Shirley, NY

Your private garden retreat awaits! tucked among lush gardens and mature trees, this spacious home offers a... Read More

Homes For Sale

$669,000

3 Bed
3 Bath
1,963 Sqft
0.17 Acre(Lot)

7 Grandview Drive, Shirley, NY

Welcome to your dream coastal escape! this beautiful cape cod-style home offers the perfect blend of charm,... Read More

Homes For Sale

$409,000

3 Bed
1 Bath
1,082 Sqft
0.11 Acre(Lot)

133 Parkwood Drive, Shirley, NY

Welcome home to this beautiful well maintained 3 bedroom 1 full bath ranch situated on a fully fenced corner... Read More

Homes For Sale

$420,000

5 Bed
2 Bath
2,050 Sqft
0.14 Acre(Lot)

83 Grandview Drive, Shirley, NY

Did you ever dream of living by the beach ? this home can make your dreams come true! need a large home ? with... Read More

Homes For Sale

$549,990

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,350 Sqft

N/C Robinson Drive, Shirley, NY

This to be built 3 bedroom colonial/there is 2 full bathrooms... one on the first floor...one on the second... Read More

Homes For Sale

$549,990

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,400 Sqft

487 Neighborhood Road, Shirley, NY

This to be built 3 bedroom cape/ the first floor has one bedroom and the second floor has 2 bedrooms/there is 2... Read More

Homes For Sale

$549,990

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,400 Sqft

N/C Fairview Drive, Shirley, NY

This to be built 3 bedroom cape/ the first floor has one bedroom and the second floor has 2 bedrooms/there is 2... Read More

Homes For Sale

$569,990

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,400 Sqft

305 Commack Road, Shirley, NY

This to be built 3 bedroom cape/ the first floor has one bedroom and the second floor has 2 bedrooms/there is 2... Read More

Homes For Sale

$549,990

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,400 Sqft

514 Neighborhood Road, Shirley, NY

This to be built 3 bedroom cape/ the first floor has one bedroom and the second floor has 2 bedrooms/there is 2... Read More

Homes For Sale

$495,000

3 Bed
3 Bath
1,588 Sqft
0.21 Acre(Lot)

52 Arpage Drive, Shirley, NY

This colonial style home features 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, formal dining room, eat in kitchen & 1 car garage. the... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$650,000

4 Bed
3 Bath
2,043 Sqft
0.75 Acre(Lot)

342 Wellwood Drive, Shirley, NY

Step into your dream home—an exquisitely renovated 4-bedroom, 3-bath ranch nestled on a generous .75-acre lot,... Read More

Homes For Sale

$439,000

3 Bed
1 Bath
1,000 Sqft

160 Northern Boulevard, Shirley, NY

Great renovated starter home with very low taxes !!. close to all.-outdoor pictures have been photo enhanced!!!... Read More

First
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Last

Shirley - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart

Homes For Sale By Owner in Shirley 78

	Average Price
2 Bed Homes For Sale in Shirley (4)	$ 406,500
3 Bed Homes For Sale in Shirley (43)	$ 490,506
4 Bed Homes For Sale in Shirley (22)	$ 556,209
5+ Bed Homes For Sale in Shirley (9)	$ 544,714

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 499,482

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 398

Condos For Sale By Owner in Shirley 2

	Average Price
2 Bed Condos For Sale in Shirley (1)	$ 529,999
4 Bed Condos For Sale in Shirley (1)	$ 715,000

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 540,488

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 909

Land For Sale By Owner in Shirley 8

	Average Price
Land For Sale in Shirley (8)	$ 486,739

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 486,739

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ N/A

Statistics Bottom Ads 1

Learn More About Shirley, New York

Currently there are 78 homes for sale, 2 condos and apartments for sale and 8 vacant land for sale in Shirley

Currently Shirley has 88 properties on the market for sale. The inventory was last updated 05/14/2025. Of these properties, 78 single family homes are for sale by their owners in Shirley, and 2 condos are for sale by their owners in Shirley. The average price of the single family homes for sale in Shirley, is $499,482, the average condo price in Shirley, is $540,488. The average price per square foot of the active inventory is $436. This is based the living area square footage.

Over the last year, there have been 0 of properties sold in Shirley. Of these properties, 0 single family homes have sold by their owners in Shirley, and 0 condos have sold by their owners in Shirley. The average sales price of the single family homes sold in Shirley, is $. Single family homes have been selling for per square foot of living area. The average sales price of the condos for sale in Shirley, is $. Condos have been selling for per square foot of living area.

The most active subdivisions with listings for sale in Shirley, are:

If you are thinking of selling your Shirley home, try our flat fee listing service, Our list fees start at $449, and may save you $15,000 in real estate commissions. Click here to start saving.

Disclaimer: Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers/lessees are advised to confirm all information IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. The MLS may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Participants and/or the MLS from liability.
This data up-to-date as of 05/14/2025

Shirley NY FSBO Homes (199)

14 Victory Avenue, Shirley, NY

192 E Parkview Drive, Shirley, NY

55 Candido Avenue, Shirley, NY

36 Westminster Drive, Shirley, NY

55 Ridgewood Drive, Shirley, NY

5 Stuart Road, Shirley, NY

36 Westminster Drive, Shirley, NY

150 Grand Avenue, Shirley, NY

10 Deer Path, Shirley, NY

7 Grandview Drive, Shirley, NY

133 Parkwood Drive, Shirley, NY

83 Grandview Drive, Shirley, NY

N/C Robinson Drive, Shirley, NY

487 Neighborhood Road, Shirley, NY

N/C Fairview Drive, Shirley, NY

305 Commack Road, Shirley, NY

514 Neighborhood Road, Shirley, NY

52 Arpage Drive, Shirley, NY

342 Wellwood Drive, Shirley, NY

160 Northern Boulevard, Shirley, NY

Nearby Cities

Popular Cities

Nearby Counties

Property Types

Shirley - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

Statistics Bottom Ads 1

Learn More About Shirley, New York

For Sale By Owner Pennsylvania

Statistics Bottom Ads 2

For Sale By Owner Florida

Statistics Bottom Ads 3

For Sale By Owner Mississippi

Statistics Bottom Ads 4

YouTube Video