Montauk NY FSBO Homes (28)

Sort By

List
Map

We have 28 homes for sale by owner in Montauk, NY. The median list price in Montauk, NY is $44,942.

Homes For Sale

$1,495,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,400 Sqft
0.1 Acre(Lot)

143 Tuthill Road, Montauk, NY

Charming beach cottage with water views in montauk: beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom beach cottage in... Read More

Condo For Sale

$1,195,000

2 Bed
3 Bath
1,800 Sqft
4.14 Acres(Lot)

52 Fairway Place #5, Montauk, NY

Welcome to 52 fairway place, an immaculate, low-maintenance, year-round condo nestled in the heart of montauk,... Read More

Homes For Sale

$2,999,999

4 Bed
3 Bath
2,080 Sqft

18 Hoppin Avenue, Montauk, NY

Start your day with a very short stroll to the one of the best surfing beaches on the east coast! enjoy a... Read More

Homes For Sale

$575,000

1 Bed
1 Bath
500 Sqft
4.75 Acres(Lot)

16 Navy Rd Navy Rd Rd #106, Montauk, NY

Welcome to your dream waterfront haven at 16 navy rd, unit 106, montauk, new york! this stunning one-bedroom,... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$1,800,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,601 Sqft
0.34 Acre(Lot)

51 Firestone Road, Montauk, NY

Rooted in history. elevated for today. crested upon a hill with stunning views of fort pond bay, rests this... Read More

Homes For Sale

$2,295,000

3 Bed
3 Bath
2,497 Sqft
0.86 Acre(Lot)

100 S Fairview Avenue, Montauk, NY

Welcome to 100 s fairview ave, montauk, new york, a spacious 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom haven nestled just off the... Read More

Homes For Sale

$1,195,000

3 Bed
3 Bath
1,480 Sqft
0.0396 Acre(Lot)

29 Fairway Place #14, Montauk, NY

This new to market south facing villa is nestled on the 4th fairway of the popular montauk downs golf course.... Read More

Condo For Sale

$1,499,000

2 Bed
2 Bath
893 Sqft
14.71 Acres(Lot)

23 Fort Pond Road, Montauk, NY

Just listed , renovated and large two bedroom, two bath condominium situated on fort pond bay with the most... Read More

Homes For Sale

$2,350,000

4 Bed
3 Bath
2,108 Sqft
0.6 Acre(Lot)

64 Fairview Avenue, Montauk, NY

Summer is around the corner!!! welcome to your dream home at 64 fireview avenue! this beautiful residence has 4... Read More

Homes For Sale

$2,149,000

2 Bed
1 Bath
893 Sqft
0.17 Acre(Lot)

28 Rehan Avenue, Montauk, NY

Ditch plains-a perfect two bedroom cottage to enjoy a summer's day or year round. new kitchen, comfortable... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$1,599,000

4 Bed
2 Bath
1,500 Sqft

157 Greenwich Street, Montauk, NY

This spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers the perfect foundation for your dream living space. with solid... Read More

Condo For Sale

$375,000

1 Bed
1 Bath
484 Sqft
8.86 Acres(Lot)

236 Edgemere Street #106, Montauk, NY

This main floor unit at the montauk manor is ready for new ownership. located on the main floor with a garden... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$1,879,000

4 Bed
3 Bath
2,160 Sqft

5 S Easton Place, Montauk, NY

Situated in the heart of montauk, this spacious 4-bedroom, 2 1/2-bath beach house offers the perfect blend of... Read More

Homes For Sale

$3,495,000

4 Bed
5 Bath
4,600 Sqft

39 Dogwood Street, Montauk, NY

Nestled on an acre in montauk's hither woods, adjacent to over a thousand acres of pristine reserve, this... Read More

Pending

Homes For Sale

$5,250,000

4 Bed
5 Bath

19 Hamilton Drive, Montauk, NY

For the first time on the market, this classic contemporary hither hills home is available. this stunning home... Read More

Homes For Sale

$3,850,000

4 Bed
5 Bath

39 Dogwood Street, Montauk, NY

Nestled on an acre in montauk's hither woods, adjacent to over a thousand acres of pristine reserve, this... Read More

Homes For Sale

$1,850,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
2,080 Sqft

36 S Delrey Road, Montauk, NY

Nestled into the montauk community, this meticulously maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath saltbox-style home offers... Read More

Homes For Sale

$1,795,000

5 Bed
2 Bath
2,250 Sqft

35 Gates Ave Ave, Montauk, NY

Create a dream moments from lake montauk. opportunity to build new or renovate the existing structures on this... Read More

Homes For Sale

$8,500,000

4 Bed
4 Bath
3,706 Sqft
0.73 Acre(Lot)

278 W Lake Drive, Montauk, NY

This custom-built waterfront estate sitting on the shores of lake montauk with 104ft of lake frontage, offers... Read More

Condo For Sale

$2,288,000

3 Bed
3 Bath
1,700 Sqft

29 East Drive #, Montauk, NY

Welcome to the pinnacle of luxury living in montauk's exclusive steppingstone community with this stunning... Read More

Montauk - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart

Homes For Sale By Owner in Montauk 5

	Average Price
2 Bed Homes For Sale in Montauk (1)	$ 3,200,000
3 Bed Homes For Sale in Montauk (1)	$ 18,000,000
4 Bed Homes For Sale in Montauk (3)	$ 3,983,333

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 8,394,444

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 5,158

Land For Sale By Owner in Montauk 1

	Average Price
Land For Sale in Montauk (1)	$ 7,033,333

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 7,033,333

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ N/A

Statistics Bottom Ads 1

Learn More About Montauk, New York

Currently there are 5 homes for sale and 1 vacant land for sale in Montauk

Currently Montauk has 6 properties on the market for sale. The inventory was last updated 05/16/2025. Of these properties, 5 single family homes are for sale by their owners in Montauk, and 0 condos are for sale by their owners in Montauk. The average price of the single family homes for sale in Montauk, is $8,394,444, the average condo price in Montauk, is $7,033,333. The average price per square foot of the active inventory is $3. This is based the living area square footage.

Over the last year, there have been 0 of properties sold in Montauk. Of these properties, 0 single family homes have sold by their owners in Montauk, and 0 condos have sold by their owners in Montauk. The average sales price of the single family homes sold in Montauk, is $. Single family homes have been selling for per square foot of living area. The average sales price of the condos for sale in Montauk, is $. Condos have been selling for per square foot of living area.

The most active subdivisions with listings for sale in Montauk, are:

If you are thinking of selling your Montauk home, try our flat fee listing service, Our list fees start at $449, and may save you $15,000 in real estate commissions. Click here to start saving.

Disclaimer: Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers/lessees are advised to confirm all information IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. The MLS may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Participants and/or the MLS from liability.
This data up-to-date as of 05/16/2025

Montauk NY FSBO Homes (28)

143 Tuthill Road, Montauk, NY

52 Fairway Place #5, Montauk, NY

18 Hoppin Avenue, Montauk, NY

16 Navy Rd Navy Rd Rd #106, Montauk, NY

51 Firestone Road, Montauk, NY

100 S Fairview Avenue, Montauk, NY

29 Fairway Place #14, Montauk, NY

23 Fort Pond Road, Montauk, NY

64 Fairview Avenue, Montauk, NY

28 Rehan Avenue, Montauk, NY

157 Greenwich Street, Montauk, NY

236 Edgemere Street #106, Montauk, NY

5 S Easton Place, Montauk, NY

39 Dogwood Street, Montauk, NY

19 Hamilton Drive, Montauk, NY

39 Dogwood Street, Montauk, NY

36 S Delrey Road, Montauk, NY

35 Gates Ave Ave, Montauk, NY

278 W Lake Drive, Montauk, NY

29 East Drive #, Montauk, NY

Nearby Cities

Popular Cities

Nearby Counties

Property Types

Montauk - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

Statistics Bottom Ads 1

Learn More About Montauk, New York

For Sale By Owner New York

Statistics Bottom Ads 2

For Sale By Owner Iowa

Statistics Bottom Ads 3

For Sale By Owner Nebraska

For Sale By Owner North Dakota

Statistics Bottom Ads 4

YouTube Video